The Problems with Pretrial Risk Assessment Tools
Risk assessment tools are billed as objective predictors of human behavior critical for reducing jail populations. But instead of providing an antidote to discrimination, pervasive human error, and mass incarceration, risk assessment tools perpetuate racial and economic bias, junk science, and the criminalization of poverty.
People are complex individuals with their own circumstances, motivations, and choices - and no tool can accurately predict human behavior.
Related content
Thanksgiving Revelations From the New York Court of Appeals
December 6, 2023NYCLU AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF: Nunez et al. v. City of NY
December 1, 2023NYCLU Submits Brief Supporting Federal Receivership at Rikers Island
December 1, 2023
Junk Science Has Stripped Thousands of New Yorkers of Their Freedom
November 21, 2023Letter to Sheriffs in New York State Regarding the Treatment of...
October 23, 2023FOIL Toolkit
August 25, 2023
S2 EP-5: What’s Stopping Progress in NY?
August 10, 2023